What to look for when buying fish at your LFS

melypr1985

totally addicted
View Badges
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
15,113
Reaction score
23,543
Location
Dallas area
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
What to look for when buying fish at your LFS


Ideally, when you buy a fish you want it to be perfectly healthy, eating right away and have a guarantee that it won’t die right away. Unfortunately, this isn’t the case at most local fish stores. Our policy at the LFS I work at is “no returns, no exceptions” and I find this to be the case at every LFS I have visited. You may find a few exceptions to this rule and if you do covet that LFS and bring them lots of business so they can stay open.


Since we don’t get a return policy or a “guarantee” then we really need to know what to look for when we go to purchase fish. The first thing you need, before even leaving the house is a quarantine tank. No matter where you get your fish and no matter how great the fish looks, you should still run them through a QT. Observation for a few weeks at a minimum is advised. Let’s go forward assuming you will be using a QT for the purposes of this article. A small note about not using one: If you forgo QT and place any fish into your display, even following my advice on how to pick a healthy fish, you still run the risk of introducing parasites and/or illness and I claim no responsibility for any death and devastation that could occur. You can find how to set up a proper QT here: http://reef2reef.com/threads/how-to-quarantine.189815/

Photo by: melypr1985
a-good-lfs-a-jpg.476037

Picking a good LFS is the first step to finding great fish. You’ll want to observe how the employees treat their customers and their livestock. Ask yourself a few questions: Are the tanks filthy? Can you see any dead fish in the tanks? Are the fish active and alert or laying on the bottom? These are all things you can see before even getting close to the tanks and will give you the first impression of the place. If you can answer, NO-NO-ACTIVE to those questions then feel free to start browsing.

photo by: melypr1985
a-good-lfs-b-jpg.476038

Now we are at the tanks. Some stores, like mine, house fish in a Fish Only system and others in systems with corals. There are reasons for this. In our case, we find that some fish don’t do well in a system with copper. While our Fish Only system always has therapeutic levels of copper in it, we never put fish in that system that we know can’t handle it. We put the more copper-sensitive fish in one of the coral systems so they have a better chance after their ruff ordeal of shipping and airport security.


Let’s look at the Fish Only system. You should assume this system currently has, or has had some level of copper in it. This is important because sub-therapeutic levels of copper can mask symptoms of parasites but not eradicate them. You can purchase a fish that shows no signs of ich, flukes or velvet only to have a break out of one, or more, of those as soon as you get it home. You can always ask an employee if there is copper in the system and what the level is, but unless they test it right there in front of you, you should take their word with a grain of salt. Another thing to consider is, this system is probably all connected to the same sump and part of one very large system. You’ve heard it before and I’ll say it again…. If you see one sick fish, they all have it.

photo by: melypr1985
a-good-lfs-d-jpg.476042

Now to the good stuff! Make sure to observe the fish at a little bit of a distance. Fish never act the same while you have your nose pressed to the glass as they would with you 5 feet away. You’re looking for aggression between the fish in each tank along with flashing, scratching, rubbing and twitching. Not sure what scratching and rubbing look like? You’ll typically see the fish very quickly dart toward a rock or the sand only to turn quickly away only grazing their body against it. These are all signs of parasites in the gills or on the body.

photo by: melypr1985
a-good-lfs-c-jpg.476040

Note that the yellow tangs in our system were housed together in a 125 but all started fighting. Now they are separated, but ratty looking.

Not seeing the flashing and scratching? The fish isn’t getting picked on by its tank mates or being overly aggressive itself? Great! Now let’s move closer. Get close and take a look. You’ll want to observe for any heavy breathing as it’s a sign of parasites in the gills or maybe something else causing the fish to not be able to get enough oxygen. Either way, it’s bad. Now look for spots (crypto) or a dusty/dirty appearance (velvet). The fish should be clear with bright color. Remember, even if you don’t see physical signs of a parasite, it can be lurking in the gills out of sight. This is why we checked for scratching, twitching and heavy breathing. The presence of less than therapeutic levels of copper in the system can mask these things as well, so this isn’t fool proof.


Let’s assume you didn’t see any of these things on the fish. Great! Now we need to assess the overall health of the fish. It should be of good weight and girth. If your able to see the spine running down the length of the fish, that’s a very underweight fish. Make sure the fins are intact and not torn and ragged. Also, look for any red spots on the body and near or on the gills, this can be a sign of infection or ammonia burn. You may see something on a fin or the body that looks like a small patch of white cauliflower. This is probably just lymphocystis which is viral and not usually a threat to the life of the fish. Think of it like a cold sore on us humans. Then we want to make sure the fish is eating. Any good fish store is going to feed the fish on request, so if they refuse for whatever reason, just walk out. Step back and watch from a short distance to see if the selected fish eats and eats well. You want to make sure it’s not just taking a bite then spitting it back out and is able to compete with its tank mates for food.


We’ve gone through the process and found the fish for you! Great! I have one more thing for you to remember. There are some things that we can’t predict. There are also some things that are easy to treat when you get a fish home. Maybe you found the perfect fish and it’s eating well at the store. You notice some scratching and maybe a white spot or two on an otherwise healthy fish. Should you forgo this fish just because of those things? If you have a quarantine tank and the meds you need for the basics, then there is no reason to leave him at the store. This whole article is to give you the tools you need to spot a healthy fish and to have an idea of what you’re dealing with if you choose to purchase a fish that may have a parasite. Do your research and have a QT in place before going shopping and you will save yourself many headaches and heartache down the road.
 
Last edited:

jsker

Reefing is all about the adventure
View Badges
Joined
Apr 11, 2015
Messages
24,974
Reaction score
79,717
Location
Saint Louis
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Great information, thank you for great write up Meredith!
 

scottedontknow

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 24, 2016
Messages
587
Reaction score
381
Location
Easton PA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Love the write up!! I can't tell you how many times I've been to a fish store and watched people buy fish without even asking to see them eat [emoji15]
 
OP
OP
melypr1985

melypr1985

totally addicted
View Badges
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
15,113
Reaction score
23,543
Location
Dallas area
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Great article. Here's a question that I have wondered about for years. How do LFSs run copper through their system and yet still use live rock in their sumps for biological filtration? Especially since I can see little critters in the sump.

I don't run live rock in my system, as you can see, but the others are probably running very low levels of copper. There are some critters that may be able to survive for a time in a system like that, it's all about individual tolerances of it.
 

azbigjohn

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 18, 2015
Messages
1,022
Reaction score
1,113
Location
Las Cruces, NM
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
If that's your fish store, Meridith, I am very jealous! The store itself, and the tanks, are wonderfully clean.

Most of the fish stores out in these parts are crammed into small store fronts, and seem to have no space, so even if the tanks look nice, the store and aisles are usually pretty cluttered and small. Alas, too many fish stores have their systems cared for by someone who doesn;t have your devotion, knowledge or dedication!
 
OP
OP
melypr1985

melypr1985

totally addicted
View Badges
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
15,113
Reaction score
23,543
Location
Dallas area
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
If that's your fish store, Meridith, I am very jealous! The store itself, and the tanks, are wonderfully clean.

Most of the fish stores out in these parts are crammed into small store fronts, and seem to have no space, so even if the tanks look nice, the store and aisles are usually pretty cluttered and small. Alas, too many fish stores have their systems cared for by someone who doesn;t have your devotion, knowledge or dedication!

Thanks. I had just spent the whole day cleaning every single tank in prep for the weekend. We have algae and the tanks aren't always pristine - mainly on monday since we don't clean much during the weekend, but we try our best :)
 

txreefer

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
329
Reaction score
331
Location
texas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is a great article and has a lot of good information. But that is the only store in DFW that does not have a guarantee on fish. All the others have at least 24hrs. Kinda makes you wonder what you are getting to begin with. I guess by using your tips though you can make a informed decision on what to buy and what not to buy.
 
OP
OP
melypr1985

melypr1985

totally addicted
View Badges
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
15,113
Reaction score
23,543
Location
Dallas area
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
This is a great article and has a lot of good information. But that is the only store in DFW that does not have a guarantee on fish. All the others have at least 24hrs. Kinda makes you wonder what you are getting to begin with. I guess by using your tips though you can make a informed decision on what to buy and what not to buy.

Well thank you sweetie! This article wasn't really written to discuss my LFS in particular, but yes... the point was in-fact to give the reader the tools to make their own decisions without having to rely on the employee of ANY lfs to guide them. Since there are many out there that would steer the customer wrong, not give full disclosure about the fish and anything that may be wrong with it, or not know enough about it to do so. I hope it helps :)
 

Lowell Lemon

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
May 23, 2015
Messages
3,926
Reaction score
16,517
Location
Washington State
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So of the elements mentioned where did we advise the customer to ask to see the stores quarantine system? If the customer should quarantine why should the store skip the process? I do know the answer in most cases is economics. Stores simply can not charge enough for the fish to go through TTM or other quarantine procedures for the recommended 76 days. So they use copper or U.V. in their holding systems and turn the fish in days not months. It seems like we are stuck in a loop of making the customer responsible for the fish health through the entire supply chain don't you think? So the store is using the management of disease instead of irradication of disease...much like fish in the wild.

In most cases copper or U.V. systems work quite well but the customer has to continue the practice at home to match the success of the store. This is not often possible for the customer due to space, budget or display limitations. What then?
 

leahfiish

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
May 19, 2016
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
2,540
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So of the elements mentioned where did we advise the customer to ask to see the stores quarantine system? If the customer should quarantine why should the store skip the process? I do know the answer in most cases is economics. Stores simply can not charge enough for the fish to go through TTM or other quarantine procedures for the recommended 76 days. So they use copper or U.V. in their holding systems and turn the fish in days not months. It seems like we are stuck in a loop of making the customer responsible for the fish health through the entire supply chain don't you think? So the store is using the management of disease instead of irradication of disease...much like fish in the wild.

In most cases copper or U.V. systems work quite well but the customer has to continue the practice at home to match the success of the store. This is not often possible for the customer due to space, budget or display limitations. What then?
Most stores will not have any kind of qt system, and even if they do it shouldn't really be relied on. The purpose of a store's qt will be different than a home tank. A better question to ask is how long has this fish been at the store?
 

Lowell Lemon

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
May 23, 2015
Messages
3,926
Reaction score
16,517
Location
Washington State
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Most stores will not have any kind of qt system, and even if they do it shouldn't really be relied on. The purpose of a store's qt will be different than a home tank. A better question to ask is how long has this fish been at the store?

I have a friend and past customer in the retail aquarium business who quatrantines all freshwater and saltwater fish before they are put into the sale displays. If you ask him or his employees they will gladly show you the system and fish in holding. Albany Aquarium in Albany, CA near Berkely. This is one store that places a premium on fish health. It is more expensive for sure but many customers appreciate the stores efforts.
 
Back
Top