There's no reason that it can't be, though, and especially if a cover on the jar is used to minimize evaporation. That can greatly assist with stabilizing parameters, and especially so if regular water changes are done. One of my jars is an old flour container and has four corals, an airstone, three sexy shrimp, and a heater. It does get direct sunlight, but the snails take care of the algae.When people do those successfully, it is usually not their first or only tank