Phytoplankton Dosing is Adding THIS Much NO3 To My System!? Check My Math?

george9

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
332
Reaction score
245
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone,
I have a 40gallon FOWLR I’ve been running for a few months now and haven’t had nitrate issues per se, but they do run upwards of 25PPM at times which is a bit higher than I’d like. My water changes have kept them around this range, but I would notice that even after a water change, NO3 would increase at a rate that was just strange sometimes. I did a 30% water change a couple days ago and got the NO3 down to between 5-10PPM but today it’s already looking around 10-15PPM 2 days later which is fishy to me. So I decided to crunch some numbers based on my phyto dosing to see if this was the culprit. I really had no clue how much NO3 could possibly be in this stuff.

I have been dosing 20-30mL (super approximate) of Phyto each day to the tank. I just received a new bottle today and made a solution of 1 part phyto and 9 parts clean seawater. So, this was 10ML phyto and 90mL clean seawater (with 0PPM nitrate). So we can ensure any NO3 in my solution is coming from the phyto. This dilution makes a clear solution that I can actually run a nitrate test on so the green tint of the phyto doesn’t skew the color of the test result

The resultant NO3 of the 1:10 solution was around 20PPM!! This means that in pure phyto and no seawater, the [NO3] is approximately 10 * 20PPM which is 200PPM of No3 in 10mL from the phytoplankton bottle. There must be some insane fertilizers in this stuff, but I am not sure because I do not culture my own phyto.

Okay. Now let’s say 20mL of phyto a day added to a 35g system (accounting for rocks and sand) would mean I am adding .00528gal (which is 20mL converted to gallons) of phytoplankton with a subsequent 200PPM nitrate concentration to a 35g volume tank with let’s say a NO3 concentration of 10PPM.

taking the ratio of these volumes:
.00528gal / 35gal = .00015

in percentage: .00015 * 100% = .015%

This means I am adding .015% of the tank volume daily in phyto (which contains 200PPM NO3).

Let’s do the calculation to see what that will bring the 10PPM existing NO3 in the tank up to with each daily dose.

.015% of a 200PPM solution mixed with 98.5% of a 10PPM solution:

.015 (200ppm) + .985 (10ppm) = 12.85PPM NO3 in the tank after the phyto addition.

Could I really possibly be dosing 2.85PPM of NO3 with each 20ML dose of phyto? Or is my math askew somewhere?

I tested my old bottle of phyto and it had about half as much nitrates as this new one, but it was about a month and a half old. Either way, this would add over 1PPM of no3 daily to the tank anyways. Still too high for me given this is NOT a nitrogen limited tank lol

We can likely safely assume the NO3 is variable between bottles and sources of phyto but man, this is significantly higher than I thought it would ever be. Curious to hear any thoughts.

Thanks for reviewing!
 

Dan_P

7500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 21, 2018
Messages
7,585
Reaction score
7,973
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone,
I have a 40gallon FOWLR I’ve been running for a few months now and haven’t had nitrate issues per se, but they do run upwards of 25PPM at times which is a bit higher than I’d like. My water changes have kept them around this range, but I would notice that even after a water change, NO3 would increase at a rate that was just strange sometimes. I did a 30% water change a couple days ago and got the NO3 down to between 5-10PPM but today it’s already looking around 10-15PPM 2 days later which is fishy to me. So I decided to crunch some numbers based on my phyto dosing to see if this was the culprit. I really had no clue how much NO3 could possibly be in this stuff.

I have been dosing 20-30mL (super approximate) of Phyto each day to the tank. I just received a new bottle today and made a solution of 1 part phyto and 9 parts clean seawater. So, this was 10ML phyto and 90mL clean seawater (with 0PPM nitrate). So we can ensure any NO3 in my solution is coming from the phyto. This dilution makes a clear solution that I can actually run a nitrate test on so the green tint of the phyto doesn’t skew the color of the test result

The resultant NO3 of the 1:10 solution was around 20PPM!! This means that in pure phyto and no seawater, the [NO3] is approximately 10 * 20PPM which is 200PPM of No3 in 10mL from the phytoplankton bottle. There must be some insane fertilizers in this stuff, but I am not sure because I do not culture my own phyto.

Okay. Now let’s say 20mL of phyto a day added to a 35g system (accounting for rocks and sand) would mean I am adding .00528gal (which is 20mL converted to gallons) of phytoplankton with a subsequent 200PPM nitrate concentration to a 35g volume tank with let’s say a NO3 concentration of 10PPM.

taking the ratio of these volumes:
.00528gal / 35gal = .00015

in percentage: .00015 * 100% = .015%

This means I am adding .015% of the tank volume daily in phyto (which contains 200PPM NO3).

Let’s do the calculation to see what that will bring the 10PPM existing NO3 in the tank up to with each daily dose.

.015% of a 200PPM solution mixed with 98.5% of a 10PPM solution:

.015 (200ppm) + .985 (10ppm) = 12.85PPM NO3 in the tank after the phyto addition.

Could I really possibly be dosing 2.85PPM of NO3 with each 20ML dose of phyto? Or is my math askew somewhere?

I tested my old bottle of phyto and it had about half as much nitrates as this new one, but it was about a month and a half old. Either way, this would add over 1PPM of no3 daily to the tank anyways. Still too high for me given this is NOT a nitrogen limited tank lol

We can likely safely assume the NO3 is variable between bottles and sources of phyto but man, this is significantly higher than I thought it would ever be. Curious to hear any thoughts.

Thanks for reviewing!
The calculation

20 mL*200ppm / (35 gal*3.8 L/gal*1000mL/L) = 4000/140,000 = 4/140 = 1/35 ppm per day

Why are you adding phytoplankton to a fish only system?
 
OP
OP
george9

george9

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
332
Reaction score
245
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
The calculation

20 mL*200ppm / (35 gal*3.8 L/gal*1000mL/L) = 4000/140,000 = 4/140 = 1/35 ppm per day

Why are you adding phytoplankton to a fish only system?
Hm so this would be significantly less than my calculation.

I have a ball sponge and was dosing to keep dinos away and keep all of the life on my Gulf live rock alive
 

Uncle99

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 22, 2018
Messages
10,536
Reaction score
16,025
Location
Province of Ontario
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone,
I have a 40gallon FOWLR I’ve been running for a few months now and haven’t had nitrate issues per se, but they do run upwards of 25PPM at times which is a bit higher than I’d like. My water changes have kept them around this range, but I would notice that even after a water change, NO3 would increase at a rate that was just strange sometimes. I did a 30% water change a couple days ago and got the NO3 down to between 5-10PPM but today it’s already looking around 10-15PPM 2 days later which is fishy to me. So I decided to crunch some numbers based on my phyto dosing to see if this was the culprit. I really had no clue how much NO3 could possibly be in this stuff.

I have been dosing 20-30mL (super approximate) of Phyto each day to the tank. I just received a new bottle today and made a solution of 1 part phyto and 9 parts clean seawater. So, this was 10ML phyto and 90mL clean seawater (with 0PPM nitrate). So we can ensure any NO3 in my solution is coming from the phyto. This dilution makes a clear solution that I can actually run a nitrate test on so the green tint of the phyto doesn’t skew the color of the test result

The resultant NO3 of the 1:10 solution was around 20PPM!! This means that in pure phyto and no seawater, the [NO3] is approximately 10 * 20PPM which is 200PPM of No3 in 10mL from the phytoplankton bottle. There must be some insane fertilizers in this stuff, but I am not sure because I do not culture my own phyto.

Okay. Now let’s say 20mL of phyto a day added to a 35g system (accounting for rocks and sand) would mean I am adding .00528gal (which is 20mL converted to gallons) of phytoplankton with a subsequent 200PPM nitrate concentration to a 35g volume tank with let’s say a NO3 concentration of 10PPM.

taking the ratio of these volumes:
.00528gal / 35gal = .00015

in percentage: .00015 * 100% = .015%

This means I am adding .015% of the tank volume daily in phyto (which contains 200PPM NO3).

Let’s do the calculation to see what that will bring the 10PPM existing NO3 in the tank up to with each daily dose.

.015% of a 200PPM solution mixed with 98.5% of a 10PPM solution:

.015 (200ppm) + .985 (10ppm) = 12.85PPM NO3 in the tank after the phyto addition.

Could I really possibly be dosing 2.85PPM of NO3 with each 20ML dose of phyto? Or is my math askew somewhere?

I tested my old bottle of phyto and it had about half as much nitrates as this new one, but it was about a month and a half old. Either way, this would add over 1PPM of no3 daily to the tank anyways. Still too high for me given this is NOT a nitrogen limited tank lol

We can likely safely assume the NO3 is variable between bottles and sources of phyto but man, this is significantly higher than I thought it would ever be. Curious to hear any thoughts.

Thanks for reviewing!
Reef nutrition brand is quite thick and dark in compare to others.
I only use maybe 40ml once per week on 250g, no change in nutrients over years.
 
OP
OP
george9

george9

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2021
Messages
332
Reaction score
245
Location
Miami
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I see where I went wrong with my calculation now. I think I was rounding a bit too much which I shouldn’t have done given how small of a volume 20ML is. 1/35 PPM = .0285 PPM which is a couple units of magnitude smaller than my original answer. Makes sense. This is clearly not the smoking gun I thought it was lol.


I have no problem with phyto dosing, but with a sponge and a desire to keep dinos at bay, I'd also dose silicate.

The dinos are long gone at this point but yes I have kicked around dosing a little silicate for the sponge but was nervous about a full blown diatom outbreak from doing so. Is it possible to dose enough for the sponge without getting a diatom outbreak?
 

Randy Holmes-Farley

Reef Chemist
View Badges
Joined
Sep 5, 2014
Messages
72,235
Reaction score
69,908
Location
Massachusetts, United States
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I see where I went wrong with my calculation now. I think I was rounding a bit too much which I shouldn’t have done given how small of a volume 20ML is. 1/35 PPM = .0285 PPM which is a couple units of magnitude smaller than my original answer. Makes sense. This is clearly not the smoking gun I thought it was lol.




The dinos are long gone at this point but yes I have kicked around dosing a little silicate for the sponge but was nervous about a full blown diatom outbreak from doing so. Is it possible to dose enough for the sponge without getting a diatom outbreak?

IMO, it's not a concern. If you get diatoms, which are expected to at least some extent, it may not be any issue, and you can always reduce or stop dosing and they will go away.
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

WHICH OF THESE CREEPY REEF CRITTERS IS MOST LIKELY TO GIVE YOU NIGHTMARES? (PICTURED IN THE THREAD)

  • The Bobbit Worm

    Votes: 47 67.1%
  • The Goblin Shark

    Votes: 4 5.7%
  • The Sea Wolf

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Giant Spider Crabs

    Votes: 1 1.4%
  • The Stargazer Fish

    Votes: 5 7.1%
  • The Giant Isopod

    Votes: 8 11.4%
  • The Giant Squid

    Votes: 1 1.4%
  • Other (Please explain!)

    Votes: 4 5.7%
Back
Top