I’m saying if you don’t pull them, fallow and treat the whole approach, they’ll die soon. We can’t ID what’s been brought in as well as we can track these same setups across posts for how disease manifests in mixed large fish systems. This is not being mean, I like this reef you’ve made a giant 300 gallon setup look as easy to handle and upgrade as a 40 gallon nano, but the rates of disease expression from the fish disease forum cannot be excluded here, they’re in effect currently
all you have read from the non quarantine group is coming undone, it’s because it only works in their reefs. For any other reef, it doesn’t work, that’s why they have zero work done in the fish disease forum but threads on their own tank range out 300 pages using all one tank example. Their method can’t work for others, it’s a full on lark of a method. When they control all the pics and disclosures in their focus thread, the option seems great.
there may be time to save this fish and the others though, you’ll need to suit up and get in and catch and get a qt tank. If you don’t want to I understand, my issue isn’t with you it’s with those who claim best practices in fish disease and are missing from every single page of work being done in the fish disease forum, their methods have terrible reproducibility but you can’t tell that in their personal tank threads it takes a read in the fish disease forum to see what’s clearly not in any single page or help option.
all you have read from the non quarantine group is coming undone, it’s because it only works in their reefs. For any other reef, it doesn’t work, that’s why they have zero work done in the fish disease forum but threads on their own tank range out 300 pages using all one tank example. Their method can’t work for others, it’s a full on lark of a method. When they control all the pics and disclosures in their focus thread, the option seems great.
there may be time to save this fish and the others though, you’ll need to suit up and get in and catch and get a qt tank. If you don’t want to I understand, my issue isn’t with you it’s with those who claim best practices in fish disease and are missing from every single page of work being done in the fish disease forum, their methods have terrible reproducibility but you can’t tell that in their personal tank threads it takes a read in the fish disease forum to see what’s clearly not in any single page or help option.
Last edited: