Hey there, did you ever do any further testing with the potassium salt brine solution? Any conclusion?
Take care.
MY OWN DIPPING REGIMEN, WITH IMPORTANT DISCLOSURE AND THE TRUTH ABOUT USING BAYER
- Thread starter Battlecorals
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)
Hey there, did you ever do any further testing with the potassium salt brine solution? Any conclusion?
Take care.
I started using Expel. I noticed that at the recommended dose, several amphipods came off my corals quickly, but did not die. They were still jerking in the bottom of the container after 15 minutes. So I did a second dip a few days later with double the concentration just a few days ago. I had no acro pests nor pods of any sort on the corals. But, I do know that the 4 acro frags are doing well.
Not much data, but I thought I would report it.
Makers Marc
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2017
- Messages
- 667
- Reaction score
- 300
Maybe I missed it. But one of the things that becomes difficult for me when dipping new corals, is maintaining temperature/water consistency on the 3-5 different buckets used throughout the process.
I prefer to use water from my DT for each step, vs mixing fresh batches.
Temperatures surely drop at each stage during each 10-15 min stage of the dip/rinse process. Do yall just have multiple heaters at play?
I prefer to use water from my DT for each step, vs mixing fresh batches.
Temperatures surely drop at each stage during each 10-15 min stage of the dip/rinse process. Do yall just have multiple heaters at play?
OP
OP
Good question! I'll admit it's always in the 80's up in my shop during the day, so I have been fortunate not to have too much trouble with temps dropping up there, but back when i was still in the basement i did for sure.
Ultimately I got a couple of little 5-watt cobalt heaters and used them when needed in my dip and rinse buckets. I always just take water from the system for the dips and rinses and such and if the temps dropped too much id just fill another bucket with newer water. would usually end up with a mini WC out of the deal as well.
Bigmatt
Community Member
Great write up as always adamOK, so truly one of the most asked about topics I discuss are those questions about dipping and QT procedure. It's also true I am nothing short of bananas when it comes to pest control, and have discussed individually with many of you, my exact dip protocol over the years.
I had been strong and vocal proponent of using Bayer on new arrivals for many years. Until one day, a customer of mine who was in the pesticides business, (who I hope will chime in here) essentially sat me down and told it to me straight, after having recommended to him Bayer like I normally did, following a really rough post dip prognosis after using one of the more popular commercial dips, where nearly all the frag I sent perished.
It was only after I myself had killed colony after colony of beautiful acropora in some of the more popular available dips, that I was finally desperate enough to try bayer myself. And I did. And it worked well. But here is the problem, as it was detailed for me with genuine concern. To use, or even recommend the use of a product like Bayer for any purpose other than its intended use, it's literally against the law. Now what does that mean? Basically, that all of us are technically breaking the law, every time we use Bayer to dip our corals in. Now ultimately it's pretty unlikely that any legal ramifications will come reigning down on the casual hobbyist using Bayer so no need to panic and start jettisoning that Bayer just yet. But in my case, having been the person who recommended its use, put me in a potentially liable position.
His example went something like this. If a customer of mine that I suggested Bayer to had a child come into contact with it and experience some kind of health problem, whether serious or minor, that I could potentially be responsible because it was my suggestion that he or she use the Bayer for a use outside of its intended purpose. Now again the chances are clearly slim that anything would go that far. But this information was all I needed to hear to become much less vocal, especially on public forums about using Bayer.
It made sense to me, and he assured me that he knew first hand, that there are people who would go to great lengths to locate and prosecute, if the situation was brought before them. So that conversation was the genesis of my search for a new dip and the end of my public advocacy for Bayer and a coral dip. I would only send people info on my dipping protocol and Bayer dosages if they requested it, and would be very clear about the risks, and re-tell exactly the example about the child as it was explained to me. Ultimately slapping a giant, “Use at your own risk banner” to every email with the Bayer regimen included.
This morning, after having sent that exact dip regime for the 100th+ time, (and yes, I always recommend a dip. No matter what. I have a zero exceptions policy, and that is the only way to go about keeping you system pest free) I felt it was finally the time to get vocal again about my exact dip regimen and to make aware some of the dangers and risks associated with using a product like Bayer as a dip. If there is anyone out there that can discredit, or validate this info, please feel free to share them here. I'd very much like to get some other perspectives on this as well from anyone else in the pesticides industry.
So, I am going to go ahead and post a copy of the exact short write up I have been sending people for a few years now. This was actually going to be a write up that I fully intended to share here on the forums years ago, but after my chat with the pesticides pro I put it back on the shelf. I have since modified and tweaked it here and there, as my methods have been refined as well, and as you’ll read have been working toward finding another dip for a long time now, as I'd like to get away from using Bayer completely.
Please make note that I am not advertising directly for any other dip here in any way. Nor am I or receiving any compensation at all for the mention of another dip. A much as I’d love to get a cupel free boxes of the stuff, I haven’t. I’m just stating that I have been using this dip with good results, and so far have not found anything else commercially available that I’d recommend instead. And if you have had good luck with another dip please feel free to share as well. Ultimately the general thrust of this write up, is to suggest a move away from Bayer, but here is the unpolished write up, complete with my exact dosages for Bayer as it stands.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Here’s a quick write up on my new arrival regimen. I am a little more aggressive on stuff coming out of QT, but I still have never found a worm at the inspection phase of anything coming out. I’d like to think that my QT is pest free as well but I don’t assume this at all.
My initial dosage is 3.5 oz bayer to about 1000ml water. If anything makes it through 15 min of that strength, I'll add another oz for good measure. I have had some acros stressed at the stronger dose, but haven't lost any yet. I have also been using a new dip by Polyp Lab called Reef Primer. I like it a lot in fact. It's clear so it's much easier to see whats going on, and it defiantly kills flatworms. Really hoping to move away from Bayer for good eventually, mostly because of longterm unknowns involved. I know that the reef primer is a safer product for sure. Still doing a double dip in Primer, then Bayer for good measure, ( see Bananas comment above) or I've even mixed them a few times now as an experiment. I generally implement a "scorched earth" type policy on new arrivals either way.
Anyway, the best defense however has been an extremely thorough inspection. I believe that this has made all the difference in my efforts to keep pests out. I’ll take each frag or colony one at a time, before they go in the dip, and in a separate small bucket I’ll baste them real hard with a flash light in my mouth. If they have even a single worm, from adults to really tiny ones, on them, I will find them at this stage. In most wholesale orders I'll usually find at least one. On stuff from hobbyist and other vendors, every so often.
If I do, I’ll isolate the worm in a small container like the pic below, and put a few drops of my prepared dip solution in there, and set my timer to 20 minutes. Usually within 10-15 min in the Primer they are immobile and/or very clearly dead, but this is not always the case when using Bayer. If they are not obviously dead, I’ll add some more bayer to the prepared dip and re-set the timer. This at least guarantees me that my dip is strong enough to kill them. If I find eggs on anything, coral, rock or plug, I toss them without hesitation. And don't believe anyone that says flatworms only lay eggs on skeleton, as illustrated in the second pic. Won't say exactly where these came from but if you are really curious let me know.
One more area of importance when using Bayer is a very thorough rinse. I like to fill up 2 five gallon buckets and a smaller bucket. Once the dip is over I'll vigorously shake them and swirl in the smaller bucket in an effort to remove any remaining critters, and to get and much of the Bayer off as possible. Then I'll let them soak for at least 5-10 minutes in the big bucket, hen again for another 5-10 in the other bucket. Sometimes I'll do three just for good measure.
Ferrell
Valuable Member
I tried out the reef primer one shot and it did real well and was gentle enough on the corals... so I purchased the big bottle $39-ouch and use one capful per 1/2 pint. Good stuff also used on an stn’ing coral and helped
stacksoner
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2018
- Messages
- 810
- Reaction score
- 1,163
Bayer is sold OTC for Joe Six Pack to spray on his lawn. This way, his kids can play around on the grass barefooted with their dog for over a month without worrying about getting bitten by critters.
As of 1999, it was the most widely used pesticide in the world.
I have yet to find any information that shows how it presents a major threat to humans. It seems that the reason why it's banned in many states is because of its impact on the environment, bees and water systems in particular. See below
en.m.wikipedia.org
As of 1999, it was the most widely used pesticide in the world.
I have yet to find any information that shows how it presents a major threat to humans. It seems that the reason why it's banned in many states is because of its impact on the environment, bees and water systems in particular. See below
Imidacloprid - Wikipedia
stacksoner
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2018
- Messages
- 810
- Reaction score
- 1,163
Target in Jersey City usually has it. If they're out, the Home Depot or Loews in Jersey City has more than you can fill an Uber trunk with.
How is the potassium salt brine solution treating you?
OP
OP
Man i wish I had more to report, this experiment has not even left the ground yet lol. But I am getting there i promise.
@Battlecorals , have you tried the Prime Coral dip on SPS? I used both the dip and in tank treatment to take care of a very nasty and iexpensive flat out infestation of philaster that were killing / infecting almost every rainbow chalice I have (almost a hundred, very few of them frags) and that worked well. When dipping it appears to kill everything and after the in tank treatment I haven't seen a pod or anything else in a month or so (nightly I sit with my microscope sampling and pulling out my hair in fear of those jerks). But I'm about to stock my tank with SPS and am looking for feedback from someone with experience.
OP
OP
HI there if you are talking about the polyp lab dip then yep absolutely. in fact i discussed some details on that dip somewhere earlier in this thread even.
@Battlecorals
Adam, are you using UWC Expel or Reef Primer, or both on SPS? I'm trying to figure out my dipping regimen, and who else better to copy, than you!
Adam, are you using UWC Expel or Reef Primer, or both on SPS? I'm trying to figure out my dipping regimen, and who else better to copy, than you!
OP
OP
Hi there,
I am actually using both now. I add a capful of primer to the expel solution for good measure. So far this has been quite effective on any living/moving critter
Thank you!
Conversation has primarily been about corals, but I’m super curious about a possible dip for snails. When you say “any living/moving critter” are you including snails? If so, that would be awesome! Thanks.
Similar threads
