Torch help

[Lostoften]

Looks like torch completely disintegrating, yesterday the one head that had been struggling looked like it was covered in a film algae. I blew it off and the other head looked great. This morning, the other head looks like the one yesterday. Not sure what to do, if anything can be done to save and/or prevent the spread to other corals.

 

[Lostoften]

A few weeks ago the tank was treated with prazipro, and the one head struggled since treatment. I have also been battling GHA, so have been trying to bring nutrients down. PO4 hit zero today, but still have GHA in tank so readings are likely lower then actual.

 

[Tinnerito]

Looks like torch completely disintegrating, yesterday the one head that had been struggling looked like it was covered in a film algae. I blew it off and the other head looked great. This morning, the other head looks like the one yesterday. Not sure what to do, if anything can be done to save and/or prevent the spread to other corals.

You're nitrates are on the low side, but I don't think at that level it would cause such sudden degradation. How is the flow in your tank? There could be a chance your coral is sitting in a dead spot. I had a coral once that died to the same two issues, with the same result.

 

[Lostoften]

This coral has been in the same spot for 60 or so days. Once tank was dosed with the prazipro, one of the heads did not look good and has been struggling. I didn’t help the matter trying to remove GHA and impacted the tentacles on the one head, but it was holding on until yesterday. The other head has looked normal until yesterday. I have been reducing NO3 and PO4 as they were elevated, and tank is running fallow. I am only currently feeding tank one cube of mysis to feed shrimp and keep bacteria alive.

 

[Lostoften]

Other corals/torches and hammers are doing well, these were added to tank more recently.

I have also recently, last week to two been dosing All-for-reef to raise kH.

 

[Tinnerito]

Other corals/torches and hammers are doing well, these were added to tank more recently.

I have also recently, last week to two been dosing All-for-reef to raise kH.

Thats good. I'm not sure then what could be happening. You should just wait for someone of higher expertise in coral to reply, because unless something is consuming or abusing the coral, I don't know what the issue could be.(beginner reefer here). Anyway good luck, and I hope your coral gets better.

 

[Lostoften]

Could this be BJD? Picked up some reef roids in hope that it’s just a drop in nutrients stressing the torch.

 

[Tinnerito]

Could this be BJD? Picked up some reef roids in hope that it’s just a drop in nutrients stressing the torch.

It could be. My corals always perk up
a day after I give them reef roids when they're in distress. But I wouldn't know why this could only be affecting that specific coral of yours. Afterall you have many other euphilia. bjd though will usually be very noticeable. I wonder if maybe theres a pest or parasite? Or some small organism inhabiting the coral making it close up?

 

[Lostoften]

After looking more at some post of BJD, I figured wasn’t worth the risk. I killed tank flow, siphoned as much as could with a pipette and then dropped the frag into a ziplock bag and removed from tank. Fingers crossed nothing else is affected if it was BJD.

 

[JayM]

Could this be BJD? Picked up some reef roids in hope that it’s just a drop in nutrients stressing the torch.

Pull it out and smell it. you'll know right away.

 

[Lostoften]

Most of it siphoned off, with the pipette. I did not notice a smell while doing so. When removing the pipette to the cup, it was leaving a long white milky color trail behind. Which I tried my best to remove as well. The frag is in a ziplock bag, but I don’t notice any smell different then that of the reef mat (aquaria smell). The frag still looks like some tentacles are attached to the skeleton but most is gone.

 

[Cichlid Dad]

How old is the setup

 

[Lostoften]

Around 6 months.

 

[Lostoften]

Lost/losing another torch today. Torch had been in tank doing well for month and half, and in its current location for 2 weeks. Yesterday didn’t seem to open up. Today seems to be melting/bailout. This will be the third torch lost in this tank.

 

[Lostoften]

Just noticed covers on wave makers were put on wrong after cleaning. Fingers crossed it was just a flow issue.

 

[Shirak]

Just noticed covers on wave makers were put on wrong after cleaning. Fingers crossed it was just a flow issue.

Can not tell anything with last photo. Need to be closer and preferably under white light. Torches can take a lot of flow. Unlikely a flow issue unless there was little/none


First photo looks like BJD.
Sounds to me like BJD in the tank and it's just popping up here and there bouncing from head to head on your Euphyllia. I would recommend in tank Cipro treatment.

If you haven't read it yet: https://www.reef2reef.com/ams/exper...iotic-treatments-for-brown-jelly-disease.791/

 

[Lostoften]

Noticed that along with having cover installed improperly, deflecting flow, somehow only had pumps set to run in direction that was at 10%.

Adjusted, to go between 40% and 20% in opposite direction.

If it was BJD, these 4 torches have been in the tank since the photo posted back on 10/10. Wouldn’t they have been impacted? I removed the previous torch out of fear of BJD but it didn’t really have a distinguished smell.

 

[Lostoften]

This is a video with 40/20 setting. I believe they were stuck on 10% and that torch was the most sheltered from flow.

 

[Shirak]

Hard to say on bjd it seems to hit randomly and the stressed polyps so may take a while to work its way around a tank. Are you still at almost zero nutrients? Torches don’t really like that.

 

[Lostoften]

Hard to say on bjd it seems to hit randomly and the stressed polyps so may take a while to work its way around a tank. Are you still at almost zero nutrients? Torches don’t really like that.

Yes, dosed No3 and PO4a couple of times, but still battling GHA.

PO4 is 0.02 and NO3 is 1 this morning