Welcome to my (near) Zero Maintenance Reef!

OP
OP
VintageReefer

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
10,571
Reaction score
17,251
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
i just noticed you don’t leave your scolys on the sand. is there a reason for that, or just personal preference? i’ve heard some debated about it so i’m curious
My scolys are a mix of placement.

My oldest scoly, I’ve had at least 3 years, has always been in the sand and never an issue
609ED866-228B-413E-B67F-ECD1EE037CCB.jpeg


0D2BF9F1-E769-4759-BBD0-2AD6DF554719.jpeg


I do notice some mesenteial filaments extending from the base to the sand bed. When I examined today with a flashlight, a bristleworm retracted under the scoly base. Possible the bristleworm spines are irritating the scoly and it’s extending filaments as a response.

Next scoly
This came mounted to a plug, I Elevated it and put it on a rock dome
C047716C-87F4-4447-9223-D7842AD251A0.jpeg


This one did not come on a plug. It has a massive 3x2 skeletal base that is flat at the bottom. I am not sure exactly how scoly grow in the wild. But it appears this was sawed clean off a rock. So maybe they don’t grow in the sand but instead attach themselves to rock or surfaces? Or maybe they just grow massive skeletal bases and someone before me sawed this flat so it could stand nicely. Regardless this one I put on a frag shelf at sandbed level just so it sits nice and it can be elevated a bit out of the sand. This one inflates over the skeletal stalk and has a nice poofy look. From being naturally elevated? Maybe. But I did notice a giant bristle worm that made a home under it, and it was causing the scoly to not inflate fully. Check another box on the theory for “bristleworms annoy sandbed corals”

AA1EDFDC-BC6B-4AEE-81B0-0B7AE2FA3E78.jpeg

ACCB287A-E1DC-48D6-83A6-5A2BA28B7A11.jpeg


This next scoly extends mesenterial filaments almost anywhere in the tank I put it. I couldn’t figure it out. I isolated it at the top of some rock work and it’s reduced the filament deployment but never is as pooofy as it was the first few weeks I had it
D499180C-18E0-4CC4-956F-982907385221.jpeg


These other two are younger scolys, they came on plugs, I put on a frag rack. I had one onthe sand and it was fine but I lost a little color and think it’s from par. I have in higher par on the shelf and the accent colors are returning

3CA065DB-EF72-4EE7-8556-DA772E74D72F.jpeg


9B27565C-DF97-4F2B-BB17-244559D878AB.jpeg
 
OP
OP
VintageReefer

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
10,571
Reaction score
17,251
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Hey I just got a plate any tips??
Screenshot_2024-11-07-16-10-56-017.jpg
Feed it regularly. And the common issue with plates is receding from the outside edges. I would keep an eye out for that beside if it ever starts to recede its easier to deal with earlier rather than later
 

Jaden9933

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 9, 2021
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
2,915
Location
Gloucester, MA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My scolys are a mix of placement.

My oldest scoly, I’ve had at least 3 years, has always been in the sand and never an issue
609ED866-228B-413E-B67F-ECD1EE037CCB.jpeg


0D2BF9F1-E769-4759-BBD0-2AD6DF554719.jpeg


I do notice some mesenteial filaments extending from the base to the sand bed. When I examined today with a flashlight, a bristleworm retracted under the scoly base. Possible the bristleworm spines are irritating the scoly and it’s extending filaments as a response.

Next scoly
This came mounted to a plug, I Elevated it and put it on a rock dome
C047716C-87F4-4447-9223-D7842AD251A0.jpeg


This one did not come on a plug. It has a massive 3x2 skeletal base that is flat at the bottom. I am not sure exactly how scoly grow in the wild. But it appears this was sawed clean off a rock. So maybe they don’t grow in the sand but instead attach themselves to rock or surfaces? Or maybe they just grow massive skeletal bases and someone before me sawed this flat so it could stand nicely. Regardless this one I put on a frag shelf at sandbed level just so it sits nice and it can be elevated a bit out of the sand. This one inflates over the skeletal stalk and has a nice poofy look. From being naturally elevated? Maybe. But I did notice a giant bristle worm that made a home under it, and it was causing the scoly to not inflate fully. Check another box on the theory for “bristleworms annoy sandbed corals”

AA1EDFDC-BC6B-4AEE-81B0-0B7AE2FA3E78.jpeg

ACCB287A-E1DC-48D6-83A6-5A2BA28B7A11.jpeg


This next scoly extends mesenterial filaments almost anywhere in the tank I put it. I couldn’t figure it out. I isolated it at the top of some rock work and it’s reduced the filament deployment but never is as pooofy as it was the first few weeks I had it
D499180C-18E0-4CC4-956F-982907385221.jpeg


These other two are younger scolys, they came on plugs, I put on a frag rack. I had one onthe sand and it was fine but I lost a little color and think it’s from par. I have in higher par on the shelf and the accent colors are returning

3CA065DB-EF72-4EE7-8556-DA772E74D72F.jpeg


9B27565C-DF97-4F2B-BB17-244559D878AB.jpeg
one of my scolys has mesenterial filaments extending from it most days and i wondered if it was caused my nitrates leaving from the sand, or anything else. been trying to figure out but no luck yet. aside from the filaments, its happy and fluffy but not the same as the first week. the other two don’t fully extend so i figured it was a placement issue. just so many things to consider
 

kingranch2003

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
May 4, 2024
Messages
1,326
Reaction score
9,766
Location
Mississippi Gulf Coast
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My scolys are a mix of placement.

My oldest scoly, I’ve had at least 3 years, has always been in the sand and never an issue
609ED866-228B-413E-B67F-ECD1EE037CCB.jpeg


0D2BF9F1-E769-4759-BBD0-2AD6DF554719.jpeg


I do notice some mesenteial filaments extending from the base to the sand bed. When I examined today with a flashlight, a bristleworm retracted under the scoly base. Possible the bristleworm spines are irritating the scoly and it’s extending filaments as a response.

Next scoly
This came mounted to a plug, I Elevated it and put it on a rock dome
C047716C-87F4-4447-9223-D7842AD251A0.jpeg


This one did not come on a plug. It has a massive 3x2 skeletal base that is flat at the bottom. I am not sure exactly how scoly grow in the wild. But it appears this was sawed clean off a rock. So maybe they don’t grow in the sand but instead attach themselves to rock or surfaces? Or maybe they just grow massive skeletal bases and someone before me sawed this flat so it could stand nicely. Regardless this one I put on a frag shelf at sandbed level just so it sits nice and it can be elevated a bit out of the sand. This one inflates over the skeletal stalk and has a nice poofy look. From being naturally elevated? Maybe. But I did notice a giant bristle worm that made a home under it, and it was causing the scoly to not inflate fully. Check another box on the theory for “bristleworms annoy sandbed corals”

AA1EDFDC-BC6B-4AEE-81B0-0B7AE2FA3E78.jpeg

ACCB287A-E1DC-48D6-83A6-5A2BA28B7A11.jpeg


This next scoly extends mesenterial filaments almost anywhere in the tank I put it. I couldn’t figure it out. I isolated it at the top of some rock work and it’s reduced the filament deployment but never is as pooofy as it was the first few weeks I had it
D499180C-18E0-4CC4-956F-982907385221.jpeg


These other two are younger scolys, they came on plugs, I put on a frag rack. I had one onthe sand and it was fine but I lost a little color and think it’s from par. I have in higher par on the shelf and the accent colors are returning

3CA065DB-EF72-4EE7-8556-DA772E74D72F.jpeg


9B27565C-DF97-4F2B-BB17-244559D878AB.jpeg
I'm interested to see how the scoly responds to the dome rock. I wonder if it'll take a more rounded (zaftig) shape? Mine is directly on the sand bed and it stays extremely flat unless it's feeding
 
OP
OP
VintageReefer

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
10,571
Reaction score
17,251
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
I'm interested to see how the scoly responds to the dome rock. I wonder if it'll take a more rounded (zaftig) shape? Mine is directly on the sand bed and it stays extremely flat unless it's feeding
We shall see! I have every scoly mounting scenario possible haha
 

twentyleagues

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
3,545
Reaction score
3,786
Location
Flint
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm interested to see how the scoly responds to the dome rock. I wonder if it'll take a more rounded (zaftig) shape? Mine is directly on the sand bed and it stays extremely flat unless it's feeding
So yours is definitely not zaftig then? Because Zaftig is anything but flat.
 
OP
OP
VintageReefer

VintageReefer

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2023
Messages
10,571
Reaction score
17,251
Location
USA
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
one of my scolys has mesenterial filaments extending from it most days and i wondered if it was caused my nitrates leaving from the sand, or anything else. been trying to figure out but no luck yet. aside from the filaments, its happy and fluffy but not the same as the first week. the other two don’t fully extend so i figured it was a placement issue. just so many things to consider
That solid orange one, on my rockwork. It looked like this for about a month

3598CE88-6619-44FF-807E-63C42AF2F23B.jpeg


But see how the right side in the pic above isn’t quite as poofy as the rest. Kinda ramps down instead of making a perfect circle.

The skeleton underneath is damaged. It came like that. You can see when it’s closed up completely. A chunk of skeleton is missing, and the scoly healed over it
1E2524E9-1770-450C-A67A-080C5E62C529.jpeg


This is the only scoly doing the filament thing, and I haven’t been able to figure it out. Tried dips and placing on sand. On stands. I’m lower flow. Higher and lower par. Finally I put it on rockwork so it would be away from any possible “chemical warfare” But it still isn’t super happy. I’m trying now to feed heavily and regularly with amino soaked foods
 

TOP 10 Trending Threads

HAVE YOU EVER ALMOST GIVEN UP ON REEFING? SHARE YOUR STORY IN THE COMMENTS!

  • Yes. I have faced situations that almost made me give up.

    Votes: 31 42.5%
  • No. I have faced adversity, but never thought about giving up.

    Votes: 19 26.0%
  • No. I have never faced a situation that made me want to give up.

    Votes: 2 2.7%
  • I have given up before, but I am reefing/planning to reef again.

    Votes: 18 24.7%
  • I have given up, and I don't plan to reef again.

    Votes: 1 1.4%
  • Other - please explain.

    Votes: 2 2.7%
Back
Top