Hawaii Fish Ban Update

[Hawaii hobbyist]

These yellow tangs will be available at the old prices…

You think you prove something with this?
While it’s unfortunate, power outages, disease outbreaks are possible. This one photo has been circulated as the end-all be-all and really it doesn’t substantiate anything except an unfortunate mistake.

Guess how many yellow tangs die in aquaculture/larviculture? Way more than are produced for sale. In fact the vast majority(many many more than what’s in your propoganda)that are hatched perish before they even drop…they’re very much alive and sentient so please dont excuse that if you’re gonna be like this.

 

[sfin52]

You think you prove something with this?
While it’s unfortunate, power outages, disease outbreaks are possible. This one photo has been circulated as the end-all be-all and really it doesn’t substantiate anything except an unfortunate mistake.

Guess how many yellow tangs die in aquaculture/larviculture? Way more than are produced for sale. In fact the vast majority(many many more than what’s in your propoganda)that are hatched perish before they even drop…they’re very much alive and sentient so please dont excuse that if you’re gonna be like this.

Funny how the fishing industry is never brought up.

 

[MnFish1]

Keep in mind that photo is from many years back, ever since then I believe there’s been a hold on targeting the Achilles, at least for certain areas, so that the population can rebound.

Correct, thats why I posted that the photo was from a while back. I have not seen it (a hold on Achilles) - but you may be correct.

 

[areefer01]

You think you prove something with this?
While it’s unfortunate, power outages, disease outbreaks are possible. This one photo has been circulated as the end-all be-all and really it doesn’t substantiate anything except an unfortunate mistake.

Guess how many yellow tangs die in aquaculture/larviculture? Way more than are produced for sale. In fact the vast majority(many many more than what’s in your propoganda)that are hatched perish before they even drop…they’re very much alive and sentient so please dont excuse that if you’re gonna be like this.

Let me first note that I agree with your comment about context and photographs or sound bites. Missused a lot and not cool. Gets spread around or talked about enough it becomes truth. In my opinion.

My reply is more on the second part of your post asking to guess how many Yellow Tangs die in aquaculture / larviculture. Traditional hobbyist, home, won't know this or have this information and therefore leaves the hobbyist to guess or take it as truth. Truth being a figure of speech not as in you are making stuff up.

I'm not trying to nit pick so I apologize but it just came across odd to me. Hope your day is well.

 

[litsoh]

Correct, thats why I posted that the photo was from a while back. I have not seen it (a hold on Achilles) - but you may be correct.

Take of pāku‘iku‘i off West Hawai‘i prohibited effective Dec 19

The State Board of Land and Natural Resources (BLNR), at its December 9 meeting, approved the adoption of Hawai‘i Administrative Rule (HAR) chapter 13-60.41 to prohibit the take of pāku‘iku‘i (Achilles Tang) within the West Hawai‘i Regional Fishery Management Area (WHRFMA) on Hawai‘i Island...

dlnr.hawaii.gov

Yep went into effect pretty recently, but I've seen other similar bans taking place for other species, which goes to show how closely the ecosystem is being watched here

 

[MT. Reefer]

Funny how the fishing industry is never brought up.

Isn't it though? I wonder how many of these folks who are in favor of the ban eat fish once a week? I guess a pretty fish is different that a salmon or Cod to them. At least I don't eat my tangs.

 

[sfin52]

Isn't it though? I wonder how many of these folks who are in favor of the ban eat fish once a week? I guess a pretty fish is different that a salmon or Cod to them. At least I don't eat my tangs.

People do eat tangs and other other big fish we kept in tanks.

 

[avm]

Any news of Hawai re open ??

 

[Js.Aqua.Project]

@vetteguy53081 @JayM @Kona Diver

Do any of you know of an update?

 

[JayM]

@vetteguy53081 @JayM @Kona Diver

Do any of you know of an update?

Haven't heard anything, but I'm sure once they're available the news will spread like wildfire.
Konadiver will likely have info before anyone else here.

 

[MnFish1]

@vetteguy53081 @JayM @Kona Diver

Do any of you know of an update?

This is the last I found which is not much of an update - https://dlnr.hawaii.gov/dar/announc...fishing open,aquarium permit is still invalid.

 

[Hawaii hobbyist]

The fishery is having its permitting meeting in early June. Stay tuned

 

[vetteguy53081]

@vetteguy53081 @JayM @Kona Diver

Do any of you know of an update?

meeting is in June. Kona has a good handle on this and will know generally up front

 

[jag10016]

just bring the $30 Yellow tangs back

 

[albano]

just bring the $30 Yellow tangs back

Never happen!

 

[Biokabe]

just bring the $30 Yellow tangs back

Probably not ever going to happen, even if Hawaii opens fully. Prices have gone up uniformly, it's unlikely that we'll ever see large-ish fish hanging out at $30 again.

I could see $50-$70 once Hawaii fully opens again and yellow tangs are no longer supply-restricted. That's where most larger fish seem to be ending up.

 

[jag10016]

As long as the Yellows are from the wild, id be happy!

 

[areefer01]

As long as the Yellows are from the wild, id be happy!

Why? There is no difference between the two other than the size and age at which the hobbyist can purchase them.

So this gets back tot he price.

 

[Reefering1]

Why? There is no difference between the two other than the size and age at which the hobbyist can purchase them.

So this gets back tot he price.

You think all the captive bred fish behave like Their wild counterparts? Clownfish are a good example... those poor fish are so inbred and tank raised they don't know what to do with an anemone..

 

[BZOFIQ]

just bring the $30 Yellow tangs back

My guess is $79-99 once the supply keeps up with demand.....I hope